Schedule 4 Index
| Contributor | Ref | Policy | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Menstrie Community Council | 1 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Various Issues: Flooding/Traffic/Access/ Lack of facilities for more residents e.g. shopping, community facilities, play facilities, sports provision, education. |
| Bett Homes | 3 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Requests alterations to the Development Guidelines for Site H50 in the Schedule of Sites. |
| Alan Campbell | 6 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Various Issues: Traffic/Flooding/Wildlife concerns. Wishes to see more detailed plans. |
| Mr & Mrs Dick | 7 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Various Issues: Flooding/Wildlife/Trees/Views. |
| Louise Cannon | 12 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Various Issues: Flooding/Wildlife/Traffic concerns. |
| John & Penelope Lee | 14 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Concern over flooding if this area is developed. |
| Ross Muirhead | 15 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | As landowner, supports the designation of site H50. |
| Sarah & Roger Ridley | 16 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Question the need for more development on greenfield sites. If large family homes are to be built, is there a demonstrable need for this type of housing? Flooding and tree preservation concerns. Erosion of green space between Menstrie and Tullibody. |
| Moira Coulter | 17 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Flooding and tree preservation concerns. No matching increase proposed for other facilities such as schools, shopping facilities, transport/public transport and health care facilities. |
| Tom Mack | 18 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Over development of Menstrie, flooding and traffic concerns. Lack of facilities available to the population of Menstrie is not being addressed. |
| Lynzie E Mack | 19 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Over development of Menstrie, road congestion, flooding and lack of facilities in the village. |
| Kenneth & Kathleen MacDonald | 20 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Flooding issues and concern over flooding closing the Tullibody road recently. Traffic concerns. Developers poor 'track record' in fulfilling obligations raises concerns over roads and educational improvements required. Lack of 'social infrastructure' in the village. Possible layout implications for current housing adjacent to the site. |
| John Gourlay | 25 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Development should not be approved until all of the residents in Menstrie Mains have been consulted. Queries why less than 25% of the units proposed are for affordable housing. Should be aware of current problems in previous phases of the development and not let them happen again, particularly in relation to SuDS pond design, drainage, open space provision and maintenance and community facilities. |
| Derek Hughes | 26 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Construction traffic should access the site only from the Tullibody road (C101). Traffic calming should be continued from the Menstrie Mains site through Middletonkerse. Any construction compound should be located in the Middletonkerse site, i.e. entirely within the boundaries of site H50 to protect the landscaped amenity areas within the developed parts of the Menstrie Mains estate. |
| John Caldwell | 27 | Site H50 - Middletonkerse, Menstrie | Flooding concerns, including impact on drainage and sewage. Access improvements to the C101 would be welcomed but it should be guaranteed that the work would be carried out. Improvements to education provision should be established. The developer questions the existence of a TPO (there are 4 areas covered by a TPO) and does not take any notice of trees on the field boundary. |
| Contributor | Ref | Policy | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jim Anderson | 21 | Site H44 - Helensfield, Clackmannan | Various Issues: Flooding/Traffic/Access/ Lack of facilities for more residents e.g. shopping, community facilities, play facilities, sports provision, education. |
| Barry Wickham | 22 | Site H44 - Helensfield, Clackmannan | Objects to the fields being built on and requests more details. |
| Bobby Anderson & 10 signatories | 23 | Site H44 - Helensfield, Clackmannan | Requesting further information on the Plan in 'simpler' terms and whether a planning consultant could be engaged at a later stage, following their representation. Seeking clarification on how the site came to be identified. Concerns over previous mine workings potentially impacting the site, and amenity issues regarding the proximity to the rail line. Scale of development in relation to Helensfield and loss of views from the bypass. Impact on wildlife. Coalescence of Helensfield and Clackmannan. |
| Mr & Mrs James McQuillan | 24 | Site H44 - Helensfield, Clackmannan | Object to the proposed roundabout access to the site, particularly in relation to the proximity to their house, and the location of a large housing development adjacent to Helensfield. Consider there are more suitable locations within existing town boundaries, although do not give any examples. |
| Maureen Wheater | 28 | Site H44 - Helensfield, Clackmannan | Concerned over devaluation of property, loss of views, noise nuisance, overshadowing, overlooking issues. Loss of 'countryside' area and green belt. There would also be adverse impacts on wildlife, drainage problems and road traffic issues. |
| Contributor | Ref | Policy | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scottish Natural Heritage | 5 | Site H45 - Forestmill | Request additional wording to the Development Guidelines for Site H45 - Forestmill. To include the requirement for further biodiversity studies at Forestmill. |
| Hermiston Securities | 10 | Site H45 - Forestmill | Support Forestmill development but question alterations to housing figures. |
| Contributor | Ref | Policy | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scottish Natural Heritage | 5 | Policy RES1a - Tourism related Golf Course Enabling Development | Request additional wording to Policy RES1a. |
| Dollar Civic Trust | 8 | Policy RES1a - Tourism related Golf Course Enabling Development | Object to the enabling policy in relation to Dollar Golf Club. Should it remain in the plan, more detail should be required. |
| Muckhart Community Council | 29 | Policy RES1a - Tourism related Golf Course Enabling Development | Wish to see the section on "Enabling Development and Tourism" removed from the Alteration. If this is not accepted by the Council then there are objections to the wording of the section and Policy RES1a in particular. |
| Contributor | Ref | Policy | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scottish Natural Heritage | 5 | Site H22 - Sauchie West, Sauchie | Request additional wording to the Development Guidelines for Site H22 - Sauchie West. To include the requirement for Landscape and Visual Assessments. |
| Contributor | Ref | Policy | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tillicoultry Community Council | 9 | Site H59 - Dollar Road, Tillicoultry | Question how the designation of Site H59, Dollar Road came about, particularly changes to the urban limit and Green Belt. |
| Contributor | Ref | Policy | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Historic Scotland | 4 | General reference to their previous suggested wording alterations. | Confirmation that they are happy that wording changes suggested at the Consultative stage have been included in the Finalised Plan. |
| Graham Nicol | 8 | Site H907 - Glentana/Dalmore Centre, West Stirling Street, Alva | Requests wording change to Development Guidelines. |
| Contributor | Ref | Policy | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Perry Hutchins | 11 | Proposed New Site east of The Glen, Coalsnaughton | Promoting site to the east of The Glen, Coalsnaughton. |
| Contributor | Ref | Policy | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Coal Authority | 2 | General references to coal extraction and sterilisation of reserves Council wide. | Prior extraction at Sauchie West/Forestmill and in general. Impact of new development on 500m separation distance. Request additional wording on ground condition investigations to identify any mining legacy issues. |
Page & Site Tools
Contact information
For further information about this page please contact:
Development Planning
Kilncraigs, Greenside Street, Alloa, FK10 1EB
Tel: 01259 450000 Fax: 01259 727453
Email: devplan@clacks.gov.uk
Or use the on-line contact form
